Mike Brown was 28 when he opened a coffee shop in Saratoga Springs, New York, and by his own account he ran it badly at first — 200 kinds of candy, 25 different coffees, and a business that couldn't support the inventory he'd bought for it. By 30, he'd sold his house and moved in with his mother to keep the shop alive. The blend that became Death Wish Coffee didn't start as a growth strategy; it started because customers kept asking him for something stronger, and he figured a highly caffeinated blend sold online might bring in an extra $5,000 a year to plug the gap. He named it after a souvenir photo of an aggressive-looking dog labeled "Death Wish" and drew the skull-and-crossbones logo himself. None of that reads like the origin story of a brand that would eventually become the country's top-selling Fair Trade and organic coffee label. But the two crises that followed — one that nearly sank the company and one that made it famous — are the actual reason it's worth studying.
The website crash that almost ended the company
In 2013, a year after the blend launched, ABC's Good Morning America ran a segment on Death Wish Coffee's "world's strongest coffee" positioning. It should have been the best morning of Brown's young company's life. Instead, the patchwork custom website he was running couldn't handle the spike — roughly 10,000 new orders came in before the site buckled, and the fulfillment operation behind it, built for a coffee shop's side hustle rather than a national retailer, had no way to keep pace. Some orders reportedly took 30 days to ship. Customers who'd ordered in good faith after seeing the segment started publicly wondering whether Death Wish was a scam, and the company was kicked off several of the online selling platforms it depended on. There was no Super Bowl-style redemption arc waiting around the corner yet — just a founder who'd been handed the exact kind of demand every small brand says it wants, and watched it nearly destroy the company's credibility instead.
The GMA-era failure wasn't a marketing problem — it was an infrastructure and fulfillment problem the brand hadn't yet built for. Three years later, when a far bigger spike arrived, that gap had been closed, and the outcome looked nothing like 2013.
Winning a multimillion-dollar Super Bowl ad for free
In 2015, Brown entered Intuit QuickBooks' "Small Business, Big Game" competition, a contest that promised the winner a professionally produced, nationally televised commercial during Super Bowl 50 — free of charge, aside from mobilizing a community voting campaign. He was up against roughly 15,000 other small businesses. Death Wish won, and ad agency RPA built the winning entry into a 30-second spot featuring a tribe of Vikings sailing a ship across a sea of black coffee, a fairly literal metaphor for the brand's caffeine-forward positioning. What that airtime was actually worth is one of the few places the public record disagrees with itself: Forbes pegged a 30-second Super Bowl 50 slot at roughly $5 million based on market rates that year, while Shopify's own account of the deal put the value closer to $7 million and cited an estimated 500 million media impressions generated by the contest win alone. Either number describes a marketing budget line a company with Death Wish's 2015 revenue — reportedly around $6 million — had no ability to buy on its own.
Replatforming before the spike hit, not after
What made the Super Bowl outcome different from the Good Morning America outcome wasn't luck — it was that Brown had spent the intervening years fixing the exact failure point that broke the company the first time. Death Wish moved onto Shopify Plus and, critically, integrated its ecommerce platform directly with Skubana, a multichannel inventory and ERP tool co-founded by Chad Rubin, so that inventory scattered across the brand's own warehouse, third-party fulfillment centers, and a distribution center could be tracked and reported on in one place instead of many. Brown described the "before" state of that data plainly: it had been "scattered in twenty different places," and the integration consolidated more than 20 of those sources into a single real-time view he could actually act on. That's not a glamorous fix. It's inventory visibility and platform stability — the unsexy infrastructure work that doesn't show up in a highlight reel, but that determines whether the next viral moment becomes a growth story or a repeat of 2013.
$2,083 a minute — and this time the site held
The commercial aired during Super Bowl 50 on February 7, 2016, and more than 150,000 people hit the Death Wish site simultaneously in its immediate aftermath. In the two hours that followed, the store did roughly $250,000 in sales — about $2,083 a minute — without the crash, the backlog, or the platform bans that followed the 2013 spike. Kane Grogan, the company's customer service manager, later made a point of not letting the moment define the brand's own account of its growth: "We don't want the Super Bowl to define us," he said. "The Super Bowl commercial was a great spotlight but we were doubling sales every year prior to it." That's a useful corrective to the version of this story that treats the ad as the whole plot — Death Wish was already compounding before Super Bowl 50; the ad accelerated a trajectory that was already pointed upward, on top of infrastructure that had already been rebuilt to survive exactly this kind of test.
From spike to sustained growth: $6 million to $20 million in a year
The numbers in the days around the game were extreme even by viral-moment standards — sales volume reportedly ran roughly 22 times higher the week before the Super Bowl than a typical week, and Super Bowl Sunday itself saw sales somewhere in the range of 20 to 25 times an average Sunday. What matters more than the single-day spike is what happened over the full year: Death Wish went from roughly $6 million in 2015 revenue to $20 million by the end of 2016, and the brand has separately reported 200% year-over-year top-line growth in the period around the ad. Distribution widened alongside the revenue — Death Wish moved onto shelves in roughly 250 Safeway locations across the West Coast, its first meaningful push from a pure ecommerce brand into grocery retail, which would eventually become the channel that carried the company to national scale.
Retention: SMS, email, and a loyalty program built around a very specific brand voice
A traffic spike that converts into a pile of one-time orders is a good week. Death Wish's more durable move was building the retention infrastructure to keep spike-driven customers on a subscription cycle long after the game ended. On the messaging side, the brand runs Klaviyo for email alongside Postscript for SMS, and rather than using SMS as a discount-blast channel, it built a recurring content hook around monthly "zodiac sign" mug drops that started in 2021 — a limited-release product tied to a specific sign, timed to a specific launch date, with QR-code sign-ups that Postscript's case study says take under five seconds to complete. The results are unusually strong for SMS: Death Wish reports averaging 64x ROI on those zodiac mug launch campaigns, with click-through rates on some sends reaching 57%, and it added more than 42,000 compliant SMS subscribers in an 18-month stretch. Kelly Spencer, the brand's communications marketing manager, has described the dependency this creates in blunt terms: "We hear from our audience if they don't get an SMS about a mug release" — which is the retention outcome every subscription brand wants and almost none achieve, a channel customers actively miss when it goes quiet.
The loyalty side tells a similar story. Death Wish runs its rewards program through Smile.io, and in June 2023 rebranded it from "Reaper Rewards" to "Ritual Rewards" specifically to align the naming with its "Society of Strong Coffee" subscription offering rather than treating loyalty and subscriptions as separate systems. To re-engage dormant members, the brand layered in a nine-week, baseball-themed gamification campaign called Swig League, splitting customers into competing teams. The year-over-year results Smile.io reports are substantial: a 186% increase in Smile-generated revenue, a 4.8x higher average order value among repeat customers, 2.63x higher purchase frequency for loyalty members versus non-members, and a 70% rewards redemption rate. The Swig League campaign specifically drove a 900% lift in revenue per recipient and a 975% lift in conversion rate against the brand's typical campaign performance. None of this works as a bolt-on tactic — it works because Death Wish had already built the ERP-and-Shopify-Plus backbone to support real-time inventory across a subscription base, a wholesale channel, and gamified limited drops running at the same time without the systems falling out of sync.
A brand voice that turned out to be defensible IP
Death Wish's retention numbers are inseparable from a brand identity that's unusually consistent for a coffee company: the skull-and-crossbones logo, matte black packaging, "world's strongest coffee" positioning, and a rebellious, heavy-metal-adjacent tone that shows up in everything from the Viking Super Bowl ad to the zodiac mug drops. That identity turned out to have value beyond marketing. In 2018, working with NASA Food Labs, Death Wish developed a freeze-dried instant version of its coffee for astronauts aboard the International Space Station — an idea that reportedly originated from a conversation with retired astronaut Nicole Stott on the brand's own "Fueled by Death Cast" podcast, in which she described missing good coffee after a tiring spacewalk. The instant blend launched to the ISS aboard a SpaceX Falcon 9 Dragon capsule from Cape Canaveral. And in October 2025, the brand's attachment to its skull-and-death branding became the subject of active litigation: Death Wish sued Liquid Death, the canned-water company known for its own skull logo and "murder your thirst" positioning, alleging that Liquid Death's trademark filing for an unreleased "Deathuccino" coffee product would confuse consumers and infringe on branding Death Wish had spent over a decade building. Whatever the outcome, the lawsuit is itself evidence that the brand identity is now treated internally as protectable IP, not just a packaging choice.
Scaling past the founder
The infrastructure work that got Death Wish through the Super Bowl also set up a less-publicized but arguably more consequential milestone: in 2021, after a nine-week process run by advisory firm Schwartz Heslin Group, the company took a strategic investment from TA Associates, one of the largest global growth private equity firms, which as of the most recent public reporting still lists Death Wish as an active portfolio company. Leadership has professionalized since — Steve Gardiner, previously head of Nature's Bakery, was named CEO in 2025, and in August 2026 the company hired Sasha Auguste, formerly of YumEarth and Kidfresh, as its first outside Chief Marketing Officer.
By that point Death Wish had also survived a real product crisis with none of the reputational damage of the 2013 crash: in September 2017 the company voluntarily recalled 11-ounce cans of its Nitro Cold Brew over a Clostridium botulinum risk, reported no illnesses, and moved on — a level of crisis handling that reflects how much operational maturity the brand had built since its earliest, most improvised years. Today Death Wish is ranked the #1 selling Fair Trade coffee brand and the #1 selling organic coffee brand in the United States according to SPINS scan data, sold in more than 25,000 retail stores nationwide, and is actively expanding its lineup — including a higher-caffeine "Power Surge" roast and a bottled multi-serve cold brew — well beyond the single blend Brown first sold to keep his coffee shop afloat.
What this means for a Shopify D2C brand
The most transferable lesson isn't the Super Bowl ad — most brands will never win a free national commercial, and chasing that kind of luck isn't a strategy. It's that Death Wish treated its 2013 failure as diagnostic rather than as bad luck. The company didn't conclude "traffic spikes are dangerous, avoid virality." It concluded "our platform and inventory visibility couldn't handle demand we should have been able to serve," and fixed that specific gap — migrating to Shopify Plus and wiring an ERP directly into it — years before the next, much larger spike arrived. Any Shopify brand that has had a near-miss with a traffic surge, a viral post, or a press hit that almost outran its fulfillment capacity is sitting on the same diagnostic information Death Wish had after Good Morning America; the question is whether it gets treated as a one-off scare or as a system to rebuild before it happens again.
The second lesson is that retention infrastructure and brand voice aren't separate workstreams — Death Wish's SMS and loyalty numbers are as strong as they are specifically because the "zodiac mug drop" and "Swig League" mechanics are extensions of a brand personality customers already recognize, not generic lifecycle templates layered on top of it. A 57% SMS click-through rate or an 887% lift in loyalty-member lifetime value doesn't come from picking the right app; it comes from customers who already have an emotional stake in the brand's identity being given a reason, on a predictable cadence, to act on that stake. And the final lesson is about timing: Death Wish didn't bring in a professional CEO, a first outside CMO, or private equity capital until the underlying growth — the ERP integration, the subscription base, the loyalty program, the retail distribution — was already proven out. The operational discipline came first; the institutional capital and leadership bench came to formalize and scale what was already working, not to build it from scratch.
About this case study.
Did Carryup work with this brand?
No — Carryup did not work with Death Wish Coffee. This is independent analysis of publicly available information (official case studies, press coverage, and reported figures — see the sources cited on this page), written to extract lessons transferable to other Shopify D2C brands. Our own client work lives on the Work page, with real, attributable results.
Does this apply if my brand is a different size or category?
The underlying mechanics — infrastructure readiness, retention systems, platform fit — are largely category-agnostic. The specific numbers will differ, but the diagnostic approach transfers.
How do I know if this problem applies to my store?
The fastest way is a direct diagnostic of your own store, tracking, and infrastructure — we can tell you within a week whether the same pattern shows up.
Related reading.
Want results like these for your brand?
Tell us about your store — we'll review your setup and tell you exactly where the opportunity is.